Serious Political Commentary for Serious Conservatives

The Independent Voice for Conservative Values
and the Conscience of the Conservative Movement
Less Government is the Best Government


“We live in a country where our nation’s legislators seem to regard the passing of laws
as far more important than enforcing the laws.”
-William Howard Taft, reprisal

Illegal Immigration and Legal Immigration

By Scott Rohter, February 2011

The subject today is immigration, illegal and legal. In the debate over immigration, legal immigration is almost never discussed! In opening this discussion I would like to give a brief history lesson. Does any one know where the word Rubicon comes from and the significance of the phrase “crossing the Rubicon?” Well for the benefit for those who don’t here is a brief explanation.

Julius Caesar was a great military commander in charge of a large contingent of Roman soldiers and he was becoming a very prominent and powerful figure in Roman politics. As such he was feared by the Roman Senate. In 49 B.C. the Roman Senate issued him an order to disband his army and not to cross the Rubicon River with it. The Rubicon River was a small river north of Rome in central Italy. (It has since been renamed) He refused to obey the order and he crossed the river with his army and his command intact, and the rest of course is history! He went on to rule Rome! Crossing the Rubicon is a phrase that means taking a bold step from which there is no turning back!

Today’s discussion is on immigration, illegal and legal. In 1951, the year I was born, the population of the United States was a little over 120 million. Eight years later in 1959, when I entered the second grade, the population of our country was almost 151 million. That’s a 30 million increase in just eight years! By the time I graduated from high school ten years later in 1969, the population was about 180 million; another 30 million increase in just ten years. The trend has been, that every eight to ten years, the population of our country grows by another 30 million people and that trend has not changed to this day!

Fast forward to the year 2010. The current population of our country is over 305 million. In other words, the population of the United States has more than doubled in the 50 years since 1959! In 1959 it was 150.8 million. In 2010 it is over 305 million people. These statistics come from our own Federal government. Let’s do the math. Start with the year 1951 when the population of our country was only 120 million.

In 1959 it was 150 million
In 1969 it was 180 million
In 1979 it was 210 million
In 1989 it was 240 million
In 1999 it was 270 million
In 2009 it was 300 million
Today in 2010 it is over 305 million people…

In the 50 years between 1959 and 2010 the population of the United States has more than doubled. At that rate, in the next 50 years, it could double again. 50 years: double the population! Another 50 years: double it again!...If we project this pattern into the future we could easily have 625 million people living in the United States by the year 2060 just one generation from now!

That’s more than the population of China was back in 1959! Even if you calculate the population growth at the slower rate of 30 million people every eight to ten years, that would still mean at a bare minimum between 450 and 500 million people by the year 2060. However you calculate it, we are going to have between 1/2 billion and 3/4 billion people living right here in the good old U.S.A., if we don’t start doing something very differently and very soon, and if you don’t think that will have an impact on your lifestyle and on your quality of life… well guess again!

To give you a comparison, China’s population in 1959 was 580 million. Our projected population by the year 2060 is between 450 and 625 million and these figures may actually be a little low because the people coming here today tend to have bigger families. We are only 100 years or just two generations behind China. In 1959 China had 580 million people. We are going to have that many people by the year 2060!

We are only 100 years or just two generations behind China! Think about that and ask yourselves if you want that to happen here, and if like me you don’t, then it’s time that we have a good discussion about immigration, both illegal and legal! It’s time we began to talk about ways that we can manage our country’s population growth. I prefer to use the word manage, rather than the word control because due to shrill voices in the media that also promote unrestricted immigration, and the dilution of our national identity and sovereignty, Americans have come to think that population control means either killing people, or limiting the amount of children that they can have! But population management doesn’t have to mean that at all!

If we start to have this national conversation now, and if we plan wisely for the future, and if we take sound steps to manage our country’s population growth by limiting immigration, then we can avoid a disastrous future. But it will surely mean population control of the worst sort, including limiting the size of families, and even killing off people in senseless no-win wars and worldwide pandemics, if we don’t! Has anyone heard the word pandemic mentioned in the news? All it takes is courage and wisdom and the certain knowledge that if we don’t tackle this issue, the consequences of failure to do so will be catastrophic!

There are definite limits to the size of sustainable populations, whether we are talking about herds of deer and elk, or populations of human beings, before Mother Nature steps in and takes over in the harshest of ways. You’ve seen the pictures of what happens in countries where the population exceeds the ability of the land to provide for its people. The famine, the starvation, and the wars over land and water. The pictures of the starving children all across the Sahel, in Ethiopia, the Sudan, Chad, and Somalia, and the conflicts in Kenya, Zimbabwe, Nigeria, and the D.R.C. over land and water resources. Are we just supposed to bring everyone here? What do you think is actually going on in the Middle East between Israel, Syria, Jordan and the Palestinians? It’s actually a battle over land and water resources. The population of these countries is rapidly growing beyond their ability to provide for their own people! All that is left of the Jordan River is a small little streamlet! It’s almost all used up, and what's left of it just about evaporates before it ever reaches the Dead Sea! The Israelis are even talking about piping in seawater from the Mediterranean, just to keep the Dead Sea from disappearing, because it is not being replenished by the Jordan River anymore! The same thing is true for the mighty Indus River in Pakistan. In former years its mouth on the Arabian Sea used to be measured in miles. It is now measured in yards!

There is ignorance and conflict and struggle going on all around us. In fact, there is real darkness! But we are not responsible for what is going on inside of other countries. We are just responsible for what goes on in our own country and within our own borders! We can only help the rest of the world so much! The rest is up to them. We can’t invite them all to come here! Where will the increased supply of food and water come from that will be necessary to feed and hydrate ¾ of a billion people right here in our own country, as we continue to grow our population through immigration, beyond our ability to provide for ourselves? We are paving over and developing some of our best agricultural land, land that is used to feed us, in order to build houses and apartments for immigrants. You can’t farm and grow food on the top of a mountain! Maybe they can do that in Mexico, but we can’t do that here! Interestingly enough most people that come here don’t want to live on the top of a mountain either. A quick glance at a topographical map will show you that 25% to 35% of the land in the United States is either deserts or mountains, unsuitable and undesirable for either farming or permanent habitation! That leaves the rest of the land to be fought over by the various competing interests.

So there are competing demands for our best land:
Food  or  Housing?
Farming and Manufacturing  or  Condominiums?
Self Sufficiency  or  Foreign Dependency for Food and Energy?

And that’s just the land! Where will the precious new supplies of water come from that will be necessary for the additional hundreds of millions of people? The answer is that they won’t be coming! There will be water wars over dwindling supplies of fresh water, as our population soars to upwards of one billion people! You already see this starting to happen between California and Arizona over the remaining water in the Colorado River. And these water wars will spread to more areas of our country as the various competing interests fight over the remaining supplies!

Yes, there are definite natural limits, and for a very young country we are already coming face to face with ours! As our population grows unchecked, we are finding out that we can no longer feed the whole world and house the whole world at the same time. You’d think that would be obvious! We cannot expand our population and our agricultural productivity indefinitely, forever! You’d think that would be obvious too! But common sense doesn’t seem to prevail. Does anyone actually believe that the United States has unlimited natural resources? There are natural limits on food and water resources and on the size of populations! Why would we ever want to approach our natural limits? There is chaos and turmoil waiting for us if we do. And there are important quality of life issues to consider as well, that accompany all of this unrestricted population growth? But what drives this population explosion is not common sense, it is dollars and cents!

With increased population growth will come all of the associated problems of overdevelopment. There will be more congestion. Like sardines in a can, or chickens in a coop, human beings will be crowded together into high density urban housing developments! As a result, there will be more stress and more anxiety, and more medications will be prescribed by doctors to alleviate stress! Have you noticed how many people are taking prescription drugs to control stress and anxiety? That’s because we are human beings, and we’re not all made to be stuffed into a can, or packed into a coop, or crammed into high-rise housing developments! We are not like chickens or sardines! I’m sure that chickens or sardines don’t even like it, being crammed into a coup or a can! If you like it, fine! But I know an awful lot of people who don’t! By the way, all of those prescription drugs are winding up in our streams and rivers that we drink from! The municipal water treatment facility has no way of removing them from the water. They affect not just the fish, but they affect all of us who drink from surface water that is provided by our local water utility company. So along with the increased congestion, there is increased pollution. I have only illustrated one example of this, but I could easily give others.

With increased population density, there is also increased crime and criminal behavior, which necessitates increased law enforcement and police powers. There will be more restrictions placed on our personal freedoms, more rules, more laws, more regulations, and of course…bigger government to make them all, which means higher taxes! There will be more cops to enforce the laws, and finally more jails built to imprison those that break them, which means higher taxes again! Does this sound like the kind of brave new world that you want to bequeath to your children?

Why would anyone want to grow the population of our country to the point that we are experiencing all of these things anyway, and we are coming face to face with these types of sustainability issues? Why would anyone want to follow in the footsteps of China and India? The reason of course is money! Dollars and cents, not common sense! There is a valuable old book that says, “The love of money is the root of all evil.” All this is the bad news, and all of these things will happen if we don’t change our country’s outdated and outmoded immigration policies and begin to do things differently!

But there is actually some good news, at least for us and the United States. If we act now, we don’t have to have limits restricting the size of our families, like China has. Our population isn’t growing because Americans are having too many children. Our population is growing because for over two hundred years we have been accepting the world’s overflowing population from other countries in Europe, Asia, Africa, and Central and South America who choose to do nothing to control their populations. Our population is growing only because of immigration, both legal and illegal. All we have to do to get control of our population is to stop illegal immigration altogether, and to put some sensible limits on legal immigration!

Illegal immigration is actually a no-brainer  in view of the circumstances I’ve outlined. I don’t even know why we have to discuss it. We all know what needs to be done on our border. It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to realize that just as easily as troops can be positioned on our Southern border to stop the flow of illegals, drugs, and crime coming into our country, they can just as easily be removed! Neither political party has had the will to deploy the troops to the border in sufficient numbers and to keep them there for long enough to get the job done. And even if they did, as soon as the troops were removed from the border, the illegal immigration flood would start all over again!

Troops are not the answer! We need a solution that once done, cannot be so easily undone! For now, the only thing that satisfies these concerns is a combination of a low-tech but virtually impregnable security fence, from one end of our Southern border at Brownsville Texas, all the way to the other end at San Diego California, backed up by the Border Patrol, plus a high-tech Electronic Security Barrier including cameras, lasers, and motion and vibration sensors. A wall like this, once built, if we can muster the political will to build it, will not be so easy to take down, and more importantly, it will be able to get the job done! If we can find the courage to build this wall, we will probably have the political courage to keep it up until the job is finally done and the conditions change, in Mexico and Central America. That’s where the problem is coming from! It’s not coming from Canada.  These folks coming into our country illegally need to stay home and fix their own country, as we need to fix ours, and that’s not being bigoted at all. I don’t have a thing against Mexicans or people from Central and South America. Most are good, honest, hardworking people, but we aren’t helping them by encouraging them to run away from their own problems! Instead, we are just enabling them, and we are also taking advantage of them! This co-dependant relationship between Mexico and the United States is not good for either of our countries!

And for all of you who still feel guilty about building a wall, in spite of everything that you’ve just heard, this wall should have a plaque on it, located at various points along the wall, and at regular interval's written both in English and in Spanish. It should read as follows lest we forget, “This wall is built in honor of all those immigrants who have left everything and come to our country legally…and in loving memory of all those who have died as a result of others who have not!”

We are a nation of immigrants, that is true! And we will always be a nation of immigrants. No one can ever take that distinction away from the United States, least of all and especially those other nations of the world who have traditionally been unfriendly toward immigration into their own countries. These countries are the very same nations that are most responsible for the world’s population explosion! And these nations are also the very same nations that keep putting pressure on us to take in more of their emigrants! By that I am referring to China, India, the countries of Africa, and Latin America, and Mexico, YES Mexico! Mexico has troops positioned on their southern border with Guatemala to prevent illegal immigrants from Central and South America from coming into their country!

I won’t be lectured to about our immigration policy by a country whose own immigration policy is much stricter than ours! None of these other nations have any business criticizing our immigration policy. Mr. Felipe Calderon has absolutely no business coming here and chastising our Congress over our immigration laws, when his own country’s laws are far more restrictive than ours! He should fix his own country’s problemos before coming here and telling us how to fix our’s. “Don’t try to pull out the mote in our eyes, Mr. Calderon until you first cast out the beam in your own eye.” And after you have first done this, and fixed all of your own country’s problems, and corrected your own flawed immigration laws and demographic nightmare, you should probably rather still keep your mouth shut, and not offer up any advice unless it’s actually asked for!... Would that be asking too much from a neighbor?

We are a nation of immigrants, with no help needed from you, Mr. Calderon, and we will always be a nation of immigrants! But we don’t always have to continue to allow such massive numbers of unrestricted immigration into our country forever, do we? Because we have done so in the past, is simply not a good enough reason to continue to do so in the future! And if we took action to severely curtail it, or to stop it altogether for the time being, that would not detract one bit from our nation’s history of welcoming people into our country! The words on the Statue of Liberty read, “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.” For over 200 years we have welcomed immigrants from all over the world into our country, so with all due respect to the Statue of Liberty and to the author of that verse that is inscribed upon it, there is another verse far older than that one that reads, “There is a time for everything, and for every purpose under heaven.” And I want to say right now, that the time, for massive, unrestricted immigration into our country, is over!

We are not a vast, unsettled, and undeveloped continent anymore, and it’s way past time that we acknowledge this in our immigration policies! Our policies need to reflect the changing conditions on the ground, and within our own borders! We cannot afford to take in the world’s “huddled masses”  anymore! There is nowhere to put them but in our already crowded cities, that would strain our already limited resources! This isn’t being stingy. It’s being smart! Enough is enough. And we need to say so once and for all! So I say to Europe, Asia, Africa, and to Mexico, and Central and South America: “Keep your tired, poor, huddled masses yearning to [be] free.” Give them the freedom that they yearn for, right there in your own country, and give us back our fruited plains and our purple mountain majesties! Manage your own country’s resources and your populations better! My country is not a dumping ground for your country’s problems or its exploding population! We just won’t allow you to take advantage of us anymore! Grow up and become responsible members of the world community! It’s time that you did! And while you’re at it, stop blaming America for everything that goes wrong in the world! Cast the beam out of your own eye, before you try to pull the mote out of our eye! Stop taking advantage of us. It’s the first step in learning how to get along with us.

And for us, it’s time for us to find the courage to do the tough thing. We need to find the resolve within us to go against world public opinion and build that wall! It won’t get any easier by waiting, and we’ve waited long enough already. It’s time for us to cross the Rubicon. In the words of a contemporary American patriot and hero, “Let’s roll!”

To listen to this article on audio, click here.

I would like to add a little clarification. A wall on our border is just the nucleus of an effective border policy. It is not the silver bullet, or a one shot solution! It is only one prong of a multipronged approach. It is the nucleus of an effective response to the ongoing violations on our border. There also needs to be mandatory employer verification of legal resident status through ‘E-Verify’, as well as stiff sanctions against employers who hire illegals. Under Congressman Stephen King’s bill, (the representative from Iowa) if an employer hires an illegal worker whose name and social security number don’t match , then the I.R.S will not allow that employer to use the wages paid out to that employee as a Federal income tax deduction. That would go a long way to stopping employers from hiring illegals, but unfortunately it would not stop all of the drugs from coming into our country or the illegals from working under the table. We still need a wall!

"The truth, the political truth, and nothing but the political truth.
A journalist has no better friend than the truth."
- Scott Rohter

Home Page

Select Related Articles
Colonizing, 21st Century Style - Illegal Immigration from Mexico
The Dream Act: A Real Nightmare
Should We Give Oregon Driver’s Licenses to Illegal Aliens? Senate Bill 845
Immigration, Illegal & Legal - Audio