Liberty Bank Failure-Papé Name Turns to Mud
FDIC and Home Federal to the Rescue
by Scott Rohter, July 2010
"Wisdom is better than silver and gold. All things you could desire cannot be compared to widsom,
but the rich have many friends."
Proverbs 3:13-15, 14:20
Dateline Eugene, Oregon, July 30, 2010
Friday at 5:00 pm on July 30, 2010 Liberty Bank was closed for good by the State of Oregon and the F.D.I.C. The five shareholders of the bank, which are the four principle members of the Papé family and Bob Fenstermacher, (a family friend) just walked away from a $30,000,000 financial obligation that they were required to meet in order to keep the doors to the bank open. Rather than pay the money and meet their financial obligation they chose instead to abandon the bank. The orphaned bank’s deposits and some of it’s liabilities were quickly assumed by Home Federal Bank of Idaho.
Fenstermacher and the Papé family didn’t open up their own wallets to "pony up" one thin dime to re-invest in the failing financial institution, even while they supposedly tried very hard to get others to come up with the required $30,000,000 to keep the bank open. But alas, no one else wanted to invest in their failing bank either. I mean really, would you want to invest in a bank where the owners and principle shareholders weren’t willing to?
So Liberty Bank will close down and re-open under a new name, Home Federal Bank of Idaho, and by arrangement with the F.D.I.C. Home Federal will take over all of Liberty Bank’s deposits and some of Liberty Bank’s bad assets, but what about the rest of Liberty Banks nonperforming loans which are really the Papé family's liabilities and Bob Fenstermacher’s liabilities, the results of all the bad decision making on their part and bad real estate development and construction loans that they made while running Liberty Bank into the ground.
The F.D.I.C. will keep $300,000,000 of Liberty Bank’s bad loans and enter it into a loss-share arrangement with the new owners of the bank on these, but they estimate that it will still cost the F.D.I.C Deposit Insurance Fund (D.I.F.) about $100,000,000. The F.D.I.C. is responsible for that, but only up to a point, because the F.D.I.C. is funded by member banks paying premiums into a pool. However there have been so many bank failures since 2008 when the recession began that even the F.D.I.C. is nearly broke. When the F.D.I.C. runs out of money the rest of the money comes from the U.S. taxpayer! That’s right, the Papé family and Bob Fenstermacher left the U.S. taxpayer probably holding the bag. Think about that the next time you want to patronize one of the many other Papé Group family of businesses like the Papé John Deere dealership or the Papé Hyster dealership or the Papé Kenworth dealership. In fact, the Papé group of companies employs over 2,000 people in 60 locations in 8 states in AK, AZ, CA, ID, MT, NV, OR and WA and has operations in construction, logging, warehousing, material handling, business aviation and trucking. Hopefully they can manage their other businesses better than they can manage other people’s money! And then there is of course the Liberty Financial Group!But hold on you say, “You’re being too hard on them, maybe they didn’t have the $30,000,000 to re-invest in the ailing bank.” Well, guess again. Last year, the Papé family sold Sanipac the largest waste hauler in Lane County to a California corporation for 43.8 million dollars. So they did in fact, have the money to keep the doors to Liberty Bank open, but instead they chose to stick others and very likely the American taxpayer with the bill! I want to know who is ever going to hold the Papé family or Bob Fenstermacher accountable? When are we ever going to go back to good sound moral and economic values in this country? 100 million dollars spread over 300 million Americans is only a little more than 30¢ per person, but we weren’t shareholders of Liberty Bank. We didn’t share in any of their profits when times were good so why should we share in any of their losses? The Papé family made plenty of money from Liberty Bank when the economy was good. Shouldn’t they have set some of that money aside for times like these? When did it become fashionable to socialize the losses while maintaining that the profits are still private?
"A journalist has no better friend than the truth." - Scott Rohter